This page has a portion of my customer testimonials/feedbacks so you can see I'm trustworthy. E-mail addresses are omitted for privacy and to fight spammers. I can provide a few people's e-mails for 'live' references if you want, just ask. You can see a few hundred more older feedbacks from my past guestbooks at Collectibles Shop's old feedbacks. Jump to navigation.

Entry #216, March 19, 2024:
Name: M Livingston
Location: Thornton, Colorado
Rating: B+
Comments: Did have initial confusion of process due to platform sales presentation. Most issues created due to my lack of reading all the relevant information. Though would prefer a direct payment (online) from the platform, seller was able to accommodate the request. Collectibles Shop reply: The initial sale came through another website that's not the easiest to use. 2nd purchase went through me directly and was fine. Customer was very understanding of the problems.

Entry #215, Feb 15, 2024:
Name: R. Pena
Location: Southampton, NY
Rating: A
Comments: Great transaction, highly recommended seller

Entry #214, Feb. 7, 2024:
Name: R.M.
Location: Madison, Wisconsin
Rating: A+
Comments: I was very pleased as a first-time buyer from Collectible Shop! They had a rare item that wasn't easy to find, and they had it at a very fair price! The seller was prompt to respond; their website has all the information on your item that you could need, and they shipped asap. My item came fast, well-packaged, and with no flaws. I'd happily buy from this site again!

Entry #213, June 6, 2023:
Name: Luis R
Location: Long Beach, CA
Rating: A+
Comments: Very happy with the service I received. You can not go wrong here.

Entry #212, March 13, 2022:
Name: K.D.
Location: Nevada
Grade: A
Comments: Excellent transaction. Fast and easy. Seller was very easy to work with and item was just as described. Will certainly do business with you in the future. Thanks again!

Entry #211, July 1, 2021:
Name: George Hudson
Location: Florida
Rating: A
Comments: very fast process, thank you for everything.

Entry #210, May 25th, 2021:
Name: Daniel
Location: Pennsylvania
Grade: A
Comments: Ordering from the Collectibles Shop has been a fantastic experience. Charles goes above and beyond in communication. Every question was answered in detail and confirmed with me before purchasing. And to that point, the items I ordered are EXACTLY as described. The photos provided really are what you are buying. The pricing is more than fair and the transaction super easy. I used the Square Invoice program, finding it very secure and direct. The shipping was right on schedule. Charles took the extra time to make sure all the items were secure and safe in the packaging, even including a checklist for verification. I absolutely recommend ordering from the Collectibles Shop. Thank you, Charles!

Entry #209. April 16, 2021:
Name: Keith
Location: Pittsburgh
Rating: A
Comments: Wonderful experience. Recommend. Amazing communication the entire process, grading was right on. Super happy with transaction. Even sent me a freebie. Will definitely order again. Thank you.

Entry #208, Jan. 25th, 2021:
Name: Joel W.
Location: Sunderland, MD
Rating: A+
Comments: Great deals, fast response, great communication and all around excellent customer service. Fast shipping and fair rates. Highly recommended! I'll be back.

Entry #207, Dec. 14, 2020:
Name: Helene
Location: Portland, OR
Rating: A
Comments: Quick shipping, was very helpful and item arrived in great condition.

Entry #206, Oct. 25, 2020:
Name: Steven Petrea
Location: Hinesville, GA
Rating: A++
Comments: I can't say enough about how awesome Charles is to work with. It was nice to revisit his site years later and find that there were a lot of great deals. He is very fair on price and he is definitely easy to work with on ordering. I highly recommend him to any comic collector.

Entry #205, Sept. 28, 2020:
Name: BJB
Location: New Jersey
Rating: A+
Great posters and magazines in superb condition, and at reasonable prices. Very professional transaction from start to finish, and speedy delivery for my order. I would definitely recommend.

Entry #204, Aug. 21, 2020:
Name: Melanie
Location: Lakeland, FL
Rating: A
Comments: Charles was fantastic to work with. He answered all of my questions and the entire process went smoothly. All items were exactly as described and promised. I would definitely buy from him again.

Entry #203, March 19, 2020:
Name: Jamie D
Location: Illinois
Rating: A+
Comments: Excellent transaction! Great Prices, communication and packaging. Highly recommended!

Entry #202, March 2, 2020:
Name: LLH
Location: Florida
Rating: A+
Comments: The collectible was described accurately, securely packed and promptly shipped. The communication was excellent from start to finish. I would buy from him again. Thanks!

Entry #201, Feb. 4, 2020:
Name: Christopher
Location: Wilton Manors, FL
Rating: Rating - A+, Outstanding
Comments: Excellent customer service, product exactly as described, professionally packaged and shipped timely. It was my pleasure dealing with you and continued success!!!

Entry #200, Jan. 3, 2020:
Name: Cynthia M.
Location: Dallas, TX
Rating: A+
Comments: I definitely recommend purchasing from The Collectibles Shop. They have great customer service. Every question and concern I had was answered immediately and accurately. My items were received packaged to perfection. They took the time to pack my breakable items in a manner in which I would receive them in one piece. I will gladly purchase from them again.

Entry #199, Jan. 22, 2019:
Name: Anthony L
Location: Norwalk, California
Rating: A+
Charles is World Class! All the comics I ordered arrived quickly, were as described if not better and packaged exceptionally well. Charles is very communicative throughout the whole process and replied to any questions had promptly. I will definitely be a repeat customer.

Entry #198, Nov. 17, 2018:
Name: Steve R.
Location: Ohio
Rating: A
Comments: This seller is a class act. I received accurate grading, excellent packaging, and quick shipping. Very pleased!

Entry #197: Oct. 23, 2018:
Name: M.W.
Location: Manassas, Virginia
Rating: A
Comments: Collectibles Shop was helpful throughout the ordering process. Questions were answered quickly via email and the items I ordered were in very good condition, much like it was advertised. I recommend making this one of your places to visit when shopping for collectibles online.

Entry #196: April 10, 2018
Name: Dan R
Location: PA
Rating: A
Comments: Items were delivered as described. Shipped promptly and securely packaged. Seller was willing to talk with me by telephone and discuss specifically what he had for sale. How many online sellers will take the time to do that? Thanks for a pleasant experience.

Entry #195: Jan. 21, 2018
Name: Eva R
Location: Terrell Tx
Rating: A
Comments: Excellent experience with this seller. He was very prompt from my initial inquiry to the shipment of my items. Very satisfied with the service provided to me and with my purchase. Highly recommend.

Entry #194: Nov. 30, 2017
Name: Geoff P
Location: Melbourne, Aust.
Rating: A+
Comments: World Class!! Charles did an outstanding job helping me purchase some 11-year-old items to be shipped here to Australia. Charles proved himself to be scrupulously honest and flexible. He kept me fully informed about every aspect of the transaction. The quality of the products he supplied were absolutely perfect. It was a real delight to deal with someone so friendly, insightful, competent and caring!

Entry #193: October 12, 2017
Name: Jack Haffner
Location: Hartford City, Indiana
Rating: A
Comments: Everything arrived just as advertised. The seller communicated better than any I’ve dealt with before.

Entry #192: August 20, 2017
Name: Jeff V.
Location: FL.
Rating: A+
Comments: Fast shipping. Great quality product. Fast on answering emails and any questions I had concerning order. Packed and shipped with care.

Entry #191 Date: August 20, 2017
Name: Mark
Location: Alabama
Rating: A+
Comments: Best packaging job I've seen. Fast and courteous. Will order again.

Entry #190 Date: May 22, 2017
Name: Eric
Location: Georgia
Rating: A
Comments: I received excellent service and speedy delivery! Charles' attention to detail, customer service, and communication is bar none. I look forward to doing business with him again. Thanks Charles!

Entry #189 Date: May 20, 2017
Name: Dave M
Location: Sioux Falls, S.D,
Rating: A
Comments: Very pleased with the product I received. Charles does a good job with fast and prompt service. A very smooth and easy transaction. Thanks again.

Entry #188 Date: March 4, 2017
Name: Casey Jade
Location: Las Vegas
Rating: A+
Comments: I got a response email almost immediately after sending my inquiry, my item was sent super promptly, and packaged immaculately! I will definitely be a return customer.

Entry #187 Date: March 3, 2017
Name: Cindy
Location: Ontario (order shipped to family in Florida)
Rating: A
Comments: fast and friendly, easy to buy from

Entry #186 Date: Jan 18, 2017
Name: MW
Location: Chicago
Rating: A
Comments: Great purchase and perfect transaction. Glad to be able to find this rare item for sale from a collector who knows what he's doing. Kept in communication with shipping tracking number and updates the whole time. Hope to buy from again. Thanks!

Entry #185 Date: Jan. 8, 2017
Name: Mike
Location: San Diego, CA
Rating: A
Comments: My order was processed quickly. The items arrived in the same condition as advertised on the website. I was very please with the purchase. Based on my experience, I would order again from the Collectibles Shop.

Entry #184 Date: Oct. 17, 2016
Name: Hannah Smith
Location: Kansas
Rating: A
Comments: There's nothing negative to say about shopping here. The website is easy to navigate, the owner responds quickly, the payment is easy to make using square invoice, and the item I purchased (a magic the gathering poster) was shipped promptly and packaged extremely well to prevent damage. I will definitely continue to stop by the website to check for more great items!

Entry #183 Date: Oct. 10, 2016
Name: D. Moler
Location: Norfolk, NE
Rating: A
Comments: Great communication, fast and well protected shipping. Thank you!

Entry #182 Date: April 6, 2016
Name: Josh
Location: Tupelo, MS
Rating: A
Comments: Quick & fast service with great communication. Item was as advertised, & it was packaged securely & arrived without issue. Highly recommended.

Entry #181 Date: March 12, 2016 6:30pm
Name: Kimberlie F
Location: Long Beach, California
Rating: A
Comments: Great site and has many items to choose from. Charles was very helpful from start to finish. The watch I purchased was more than I expected. I will purchase again from this site. Very trustworthy gentleman and site.

Entry #180 Date: Nov 26 2015 8:40pm
Name: David S.
Location: Indiana
Rating: A+
Comments: Charles the owner is very helpful and informative on the products that he has to offer. He went above and beyond when I emailed him asking about a particular artist that he has featured on his website. I was interested in a particular print that I had seen about 12 years ago. He put me in touch with the artist's husband and I wound up buying the ORIGINAL painting that I had been looking for. Nothing but good service and honesty at this website.

Entry #179 Date: Nov 16 2015 8:10pm
Name: Steve
Location: Pennsylvania
Rating: A
Comments: The comics were as described, maybe even better! The prices were very cheap and affordable, way under guide. Will definitely do business again! Thanks!

Entry #178 Date: Nov 10 2015 12:35am
Name: Jon Abbott
Location: Alexandria, VA
Rating: A+
Comments: Beautiful transaction. Very helpful and communicative. Super fast shipment. Great deal. I am very happy.

Entry #177 Date: June 4 2015 4:30pm
Name: James "JB" Sudderth
Location: Houston (Texas)
Rating: A+
Comments: I have bought several thousand dollars in collectibles from Charles over the years and always found him to be very trustworthy with the money, speed of service, communications, and descriptions of the items he sells.

Entry #176 Date: Dec. 3 2014 5pm
Name: Alex
Location: NJ
Rating: A
Comments: Have made 2 orders, very satisfied with both. The seller paid constant attention to the orders, and the comics arrived well packed and cared for.

Entry #175 Date: Sep 22 2014 10:10:54
Name: Kimberly
Location: Alexandria, Virginia
Comments: Fantastic service. The product I purchased was in perfect condition. Chuck had very prompt and continuous communication during the whole transaction. I highly recommend this shop! Very satisfied- thank you! :)
Rating: A

Entry #174 Date: Aug 13 2014 05:07:43
Name: Joe Woodson
Location: West Covina, CA
Comments: What a great experience! I got the book I wanted at a great price and the service was second to none. Great customer service.
Rating: A

Entry #173 Date: Jun 23 2014 08:42:12
Name: Jon Pierracos
Location: Plano TX
Comments: Thanks for the great deal, excellent communication & very fast shipping of the Batman TAS FOX dealer promo 3D pop-up book. Arrived in perfect condition and is spectacular!
Rating: A

Entry #172 Date: Jan 14 2014 04:19:55
Name: William Woolley
Location: Mishawaka, IN
Comments: Thanks for the products! Nice Pieces! Thanks.
Rating: A

Entry #171 Date: Nov 25 2013 01:11:38
Name: Amanda Johnson
Location: Ventura, CA
Comments: Great shipping! Thanks for the Inquest magazine!
Rating: A

Entry #170 Date: Nov 4 2013 06:56:48
Name: Peter Gerner
Location: New Jersey
Comments: Amazing deal on a Mego die cast Spiderman MIB. Excellent condition item with excellent packaging and quick shipment. A++++ all the way. Thank you, Charles!
Rating: A

Entry #169 Date: Jun 16 2013 07:15:10
Name: Andrew R
Location: NJ
Comments: Charles is an old school collector/dealer. You can't beat his prices. Condition of items was exactly as described. Communication/responsiveness was incredible. It was an absolute pleasure doing business with him. It's awesome to know people like Charles are still out there.
Rating: A

Entry #168 Date: May 14 2013 04:17:35
Name: Larry
Location: Oklahoma City, OK
Comments: Great grading, great prices, great mailing.
Rating: A

Entry #167 Date: May 1 2013 02:27:57
Name: Stephanie Ruocchio
Location: Perth - Western Australia
Comments: A pleasure to deal with! Everything arrived as per the pictures on the website! Packaging was brilliant! Thanks again!
Rating: A

Entry #166 Date: Apr 20 2013 04:07:53
Name: Andreas
Location: Clermont
Comments: Awesome service, fast shipping, great product.
Rating: A

Entry #165 Date: Mar 6 2013 01:36:49
Name: Daniel J Reitz Sr
Location: Ohio
Comments: Very pleased with items purchased. Great customer service!
Rating: A

Entry #164 Date: Mar 5 2013 04:11:36
Name: Richard Trella
Location: Inverness Fl.
Comments: Very straight forward. Good pricing and quality. Excellent service and honest product description. The kind of place you would go back and buy again.
Rating: A

Entry #163 Date: Feb 23 2013 07:05:37
Name: James
Location: Pennsylvania
Comments: Good service, fast shipment, I got just what I had asked for.
Rating: A

Entry #162 Date: Feb 11 2013 04:20:50
Name: michele bright
Location: Corpus Christi, TX
Comments: Love this seller and items. Awesome packaging, fantastic communication, and customer service. Will be buying from seller again. Very happy.
Rating: A

Entry #161 Date: Feb 4 2013 03:59:43
Name: Bill Callaghan
Location: Richmond, VA
Comments: Great transaction, great communication and shipping, highly recommend this seller.
Rating: A

Entry #160 Date: Jan 2 2013 01:40:30
Name: Tanya
Location: Australia
Comments: Good communication with seller. The Office calendar 2007 arrived in excellent condition!
Rating A

Back to top